I've been a Cook fan since day 1...love love love him!!! My mom likes Archuletta though so there is definately going to be a fight next week before the reveal ...I like both of them but when I think about which one I would actually go out a buy their cd its definately Cook...I just can't imagine Archuletta singing songs like "with you" he did a great job but it really wasn't "him" hes so adorable but BOO is not something that should come out of his mouth! He's done almost nothing but balads from day 1 and after a while, they all sound the same for me.

The judges are right though either of the Davids could sing the phone book and make it sound good lol...

Syesha on the other hand...good luck girl! You're gonna need it to make it past these two!

David cook was so boring   And "with you" SO did not fit him at all.  Seriously, could you see him singing that stuff on the radio?    Not a fan.  Loved David cook as usual and Syeesha actually sounded good with the Alicia Keys song, she's kinds grown on me, but she will probably leave.  David A.  is just to much like another Taylor Hicks.....he sounds good but he will disappear as fast as he showed up.

love love love David A. When he said Billy Joel acapella (or  however  you spell it) I had goosebumps!!  I don't know if he makes it big where he will fit in, like pop, country, rock??

David Cook is good too but I am just not a fan or the whole rocker thing.

Syesha, I have been waiting for her to go home since day one, I am hoping I see that today!!

I love Simon, he is just so awesome.

Last night was predictable although in years past there have been big surprises! It is down to the Davids and it could go either way!

I wanted to see him yell out " holy s** that's a lot of people"!!   

That is the expression I used watching Fantasia!!!!!

Maybe this year it will totally rock!! 

I am pulling for Archuletta but would be happy if Cook won too.

Boy Fantasia, fame really changed her huh. and did she put on some weight?/

I was uncomfortable watching her performance, I wonder what the heck she thought when she watched it back??!!

Paula must write them then

I watched it last night while waiting for Dancing with the Stars to come on.  So which David do you think will win?  I think the little boy is more in keeping with the type of Idol they like.  Does he ever sing anything except ballads? 

The older David seems like he wouldn't want to make the kind of album they would want him to make.  He might be better off coming in second place.

yea! your probably right...I like Cook better! he atleast has some range and is a better all around singer...I'd buy his CD but little "archy? no...maybe if I was 80+ I hope they don't make the same mistake they did with Daughtry! no look at him!!! And Cook sounds JUST LIKE HIM! and how do they expect to sell CD's with Archy anyway>? what would he sing? lullaby's to old ladys' MEN by CD's too! its would be like Barry Manalo music!no body will buy it! maybe TWEENS!

yeeeeaaaa....why so long!!!do they tihink people REALLY care about the 2 hours of FILL TIME!!